Not every tree needs a stake, and in a sheltered garden many are better off without one. A young tree that is allowed to sway in the wind builds a thicker, stronger trunk and a wider root plate, because the movement stimulates what arborists call reaction wood. Staked too firmly and for too long, that same tree can end up weak at the base, unable to stand on its own when the ties finally come off.
That said, staking is genuinely useful in certain situations. Reach for a stake if you are planting on an exposed site — a windy corner of a garden, an open field edge, a coastal plot — or if the tree is large for its root system, such as a container-grown specimen with a hefty canopy. Bare-root whips planted in a sheltered border, on the other hand, usually do best left to their own devices.
As a rule of thumb, stake when the tree cannot hold itself upright on its own roots, and remove the support as soon as it can.
For most garden trees, a single round timber stake is enough. Use a sturdy one — 50mm to 75mm diameter — and drive it in before planting, so you are not forcing it through the rootball afterwards. Aim for roughly a third of the tree's height above ground, which usually means a 1.5m stake for a standard young tree.
Position matters more than many people realise:
Aim for the stake to sit firmly enough that you cannot wobble it by hand. If it moves, the tree moves with it, and you have achieved nothing.
The tie is where most staking goes wrong. Rigid ties and tight knots girdle the trunk, cutting into the bark as the tree grows and strangling the flow of sap. Use a proper adjustable tree tie with a rubber or fabric cushion, or a wide strip of hessian or webbing. Never use wire, string or cable ties directly against the bark.
Fix the tie in a figure-of-eight, so the trunk and stake are held separately with the crossing point between them. This keeps the trunk from rubbing on the stake while still allowing a little movement. As a test, the trunk should be able to shift roughly 2–5cm in any direction. If it is rock solid, the tie is too tight.
Check ties every spring and again in late summer. Loosen them as the trunk thickens, and move the tie up or down slightly to avoid pressure sores on one spot of bark. A tree that grows into its tie will be permanently marked, and sometimes killed outright.
Staking is only one part of getting a young tree away well. Plant at the same depth it was growing before — look for the flare where the trunk widens into the roots, and keep that flare at soil level. Planting too deep is a common and often fatal mistake.
After planting, water thoroughly to settle the soil around the roots, then mulch with a ring of well-rotted bark or compost, 5–7cm deep and kept clear of the trunk itself. The mulch suppresses weeds and holds moisture, which matters far more than the stake in the tree's first two summers.
Watering is where newly planted trees live or die. In the first two growing seasons, give a container-grown tree around 10–20 litres a week in dry weather, poured slowly so it soaks in rather than running off. Bare-root trees planted in autumn usually need less, but a dry spring will still call for a can or two.
This is the step most gardeners skip, and it undoes much of the good work. A tree left staked for years grows dependent on the support, developing a thin trunk and a weak root plate. The stake should come out after two growing seasons at most — often after one, for smaller whips.
Late summer or early autumn is a good time to remove it, when the tree has finished its main flush of growth and the soil is still warm enough for roots to keep settling. Loosen the tie first, wait a week or two, then pull the stake. If the tree leans badly or the rootball lifts, firm it back in and give it one more season.
Once the stake is out, keep an eye on the tree through its first windy winter. Most will stand perfectly well. Those that do not were probably never ready, and a further season of gentle support will see them right.
Leave A Comment